8
Jan
Kerala, from a Woman’s Point of View
I feel like I am trapped.
I have lost all sense of myself since coming here.
I am living someone’s life. Who’s? Not mine.
Before I made the move to Kerala I was so excited. My husband and I both were excited. I had been here before and loved it. Maybe I loved it because it was a vacation and not a life move. I have been here for almost five months now. I am engulfed in the culture, and I am struggling.
I am struggling mostly because I am a woman in this society. Kerala is a male dominated society. Everything positive I had heard about the lives women lead here in Kerala was false. Little did I know, the respect this society has for women is purely a myth. Yes, life in Kerala for women has come a long way from where is used to be, but it is nowhere near where it should be in today’s world.
When I go out on the street I have learned to walk as far away from others as I can. The reason is because I have had so many men touch me inappropriately and then act like it was a mistake. I now understand the reason for women’s lines in all public places. Really, though, the women’s lines don’t work. While the women are in the line, men are harassing them from the men’s line. This is the same reason there is a woman’s area on all buses. That doesn’t work either because once the bus has more people then the capacity allows there are plenty of men in there copping a feel acting like they can’t help it.
I was at the movies a couple weeks ago and the theater was packed. The guy that was sitting next to me slowly kept moving his arm into my seat until I was squished into the other side of the seat so that he wouldn’t touch me. Seriously, almost the entire right side of his body was in my chair. My husband switched seats with me in the middle of the movie and all of the sudden the guy and all of his body parts never made it over the barrier of his chair.
Young women in Kerala now are more career oriented than ever, but it doesn’t last long. Once women get married they find their husband doesn’t want a working woman so she is forced to quit her job and stay home. Men expect the woman to run the house and cook all the meals and that is what happens here.
It seems that everyday there is a news story about how a woman in India got raped or molested. The sad part about the news stories is that there is ALWAYS someone saying that it is the woman’s fault. One such story was about a rickshaw driver who raped a woman. It was her fault because she needed to go somewhere and had to take a rickshaw? The really really really messed up part is that in every story there seems to always be a politician saying that it’s the woman’s fault for the rape or molestation. Who is electing these politicians? The women who are reporting these crimes is a very small percentage. Once a rape or molestation is reported often times the woman’s family is embarrassed of their daughter or wife. She will sometimes get shunned by her own family.
I have met so many guys in their early 20’s that want to meet a woman, but say it is tough in Kerala. They say that women here are standoffish and not interested. Well, society has made them that way.
Women hold office, can drive, work, and can do anything a man can do, but they are not respected for any of that. Men ignore all of that and the woman in India has one title that stands above all; WOMAN. She will be ridiculed and put down and forced to change her life because the man said so.
To the rest of India, Kerala looks great because it has the highest educated population and close to 100% literacy. Education and literacy will do nothing for your state as long as society lives like it is in the dark ages. Kerala also has the highest suicide rate. In fact the suicide rate here in Kerala is more than double the rest of India.
Don’t believe all of the great stuff that you hear about women lives in Kerala. I scoff when I hear people say that women in Kerala live comparable lives to women in developed countries. It just isn’t true.
January 8th, 2010 at 4:04 pm
Ohh, I am sorry for your bad experience in Kerala. You know I am too a keralite, But I too feel Kerala society is really bad with Politicans, Bad Males & Inequality.
Only way of changing this is by making a revolution like The Womens Revolutionary society.
You all are very unsafe in Kerala, Please dont walk at night through footpaths and wear similar dress Indians wears.
Many women like you goes crying. But you shouldnt be like this. There is Supreme Court & Laws & Come to India as a Gang with males, If anything happens atleast shoot them
January 8th, 2010 at 4:44 pm
Absolutely true ! I second everything you have said. I lived a charmed and liberal life. But I may be part of a miniscule percentage of women in kerala who live such lives. My housemaid suffers silently when her husband drinks and beats her up. I tried to talk to him, but he thought I was interfering in their private life. I have met young women who thought marriage would be the ultimate happiness . And after marriage they realise what a mistake they made. I am not generalising, but, its most often the case. And I’m also not talking of the many young men and women in all strata of society , who have perfectly happy marriages.
Who is to blame for this malaise ? The young men grow up seeing their fathers beating up their mothers and they think it is their right to do the same to their wives. The girls who see this happening in their own homes, think they can escape by getting married, but sadly, the story is repeated.
But , this is not true of only Kerala. In other states of India , one hears of mothers aiding and abetting their sons in burning to death their daughters in law, because they have not brought in enough of dowry . Girl children are aborted ,or sometimes discarded after they are born . Hard to believe in this century – but its true.
About the cinema theatre and bus travel, when I was a schoolgirl, we used to go to theatres and travel on buses with large pins in our hands. Anyone who tried to misbehave got it from us. I taught my two daughters to do the same, and my elder girl once broke a guys nose when he tried to touch her on a bus. She was applauded by the other women in the bus !! Sad state of affairs , but nothing much has changed over the years.
January 8th, 2010 at 5:45 pm
Honour your feelings. You have Picturised recent kerala. Hope our state will change to Gods own country as it mean
January 8th, 2010 at 5:57 pm
Its always a sad thing that a foreigner (and a woman especially) has to meet unscrupulous people the hard way. We should teach the equality of sexes and respect for all people from 1st grade itself. I recall a subject called moral science, but no mention of respect for women. Here as always, women are expected to be saints.
It will do wonders if kids are taught to praise the equality of the sexes along with all the other stuff being drilled into young minds today: respect for parents, the virtues of democracy, unity in diversity, civic sense etc. Its high time that the people reject any bias against half its population, as wave after wave of scientific evidence rolls in, the bias has no solid ground to stand on.
January 9th, 2010 at 1:25 am
Well, i totally agree with your views, anyhow, i believe, u are in one of the safest places in India.
January 9th, 2010 at 1:43 am
Though it is a true post about the women and the sufferings of women in Kerala, not all the women suffer the same thing. As a woman she always had the fear in her mind that she is a women and she will be the target for the rest of the men in the society. I am also a Kerala woman who did her studies till the bachelors from Kerala schools and colleges. I have heard so many stories about the bad experience from my friends in the buses, theatres and almost all the public places. 95% of these girls never reacted to the situation and the men behind this use that like anything. I also had a bad experience in a theatre. But what I did to that man would have made him to stop all these IMMATURE activities. So women should be courageous to do things as the reflex to those activities. Education in a right way and the growing family background are the main reason which changes the girls mind. As Melissa noted Kerala is a male dominating society. Even in almost all the houses boys are treated one step above the girls. So from the childhood itself mind of boys will be like a dominating kind and girls will be ready to accept this fact. If there is no change in this behavior from the parents (most of them are well educated, still) then the situation will be the same for always…
January 9th, 2010 at 6:04 am
Your correct. Average women in kerala is the same as you mentioned. Women facing all kind dirty things when they goes in public places. Everyone lives in kerala knows these matters. Sometimes too much democracy & politics can cause these kinda issues and laws are not correctly implemented.
I have seen these kinda issues, a few ladies in upper middle class or upper class are enjoying the full freedom as they r capable of tackling things. issues are present in that class as well.
I have noticed one people wont response to what happens to others in kerala. This is a big issue in kerala. i studied in neighbouring state tamilnadu, i have seen there , when a man is doing dirty things or says bad words to a women , all the people around will come for the help of the lady and beat him.
this is missing in kerala, if this was there in kerala it was good and other maniacs wont repeat the same thing.
nowadays its becoming “Devil’s own country”
Sorry for ur bad exp in kerala.
January 9th, 2010 at 7:10 am
First of All ,before starting to speak , let me thank you for such a great article . Indeed you have spoken the truth in its most plain manner on behalf of a large multitude of people including me. Being a keralite for the last 21 years i never realized how this place could be a God’s own country , when it accommodates of ‘satans’ (even though the scenic beauty is awesome) . Anyway I don’t think the attitude will change because each new generation here are spoon fed with the dessert of ideologies these people posses.. Only a few do use their brains, and only a few among them do really act upon it…
Sad to hear about your experience,even though you were a guest , but the fact is, this is what almost every female in kerala whether she is of 10yrs or living in her mid 50’s faces everyday . And this has become so common, that (almost) every girl has lost her ability to react and has learned to ‘take it easy'(as it is taught by their male counter parts) , the mothers now teach their daughters that this is what is meant to be a ‘woman’ . .
I wish you best of luck ‘exploring’ kerala and bringing out more like these.
January 10th, 2010 at 1:35 am
Agrees completely. The society puts so much pressure on you, you totally become a mix of what society wants and the real you ,slowly sacrificing the person you really are.
Keep your wits and save your sanity.
January 11th, 2010 at 1:27 pm
You are right, this kind of features are written by many ppl, published by many dailies. But unless the man changes, the writings cant make a difference. Yes, thanks for the writeup, atleast it will bring awareness or remind woman/girls once again about the happenings in public and private.
Take care woman…
January 15th, 2010 at 12:54 pm
Dear Melisa, Some of the points you mentioned here are right. I strongly support you. In theaters this happens, many times I felt akward by seeing these stuffs! There are some points I strongly disagree with you. Man never want women to be in kitchen, a young and common man like me think of a women who takes acre of me, home and kids. If I say wife (future tense:) ) ‘You don’t go for work’ , It does not mean that I want she to be in kitchen. Think positively here; I wish I dont want my wife to struggle at work place. Hw much preassure an individual have? Work+life etc.. iF you and ur husband are working, will your child get proper attention? I mean personal touch a mother can give..atleast the 1st 5-6 years of childhood?? When your kids return from school if theyr hungry they need to wait late evening till his/her mother comes aftr work, aftr work mother won’t be in a position to cook 4 the kid. This is whats happening in society today. You may get a ‘paid mother’ there in the form of a maid. But this won’t give any personal care to a kid! Plz never think malayali husbands are dominating! 🙂 Its unfortunate that girls often undersatnd this. Girls should be given freedom to work untill they become a mother! After that please..for your kid!
If you wish to write any comment on me plz do @ ashwinkodoth@gmail.com
January 17th, 2010 at 11:57 am
really sad for ur experience in Kerala.. being from the ‘male’ category is really embarassing me now.. i personally always try my best to present the best face of Kerala, nd wud try and help any stranded and confused tourist ( including tourists frm India )
January 17th, 2010 at 12:00 pm
and I really feel like apologising on behalf of Kerala nd India for all ur misadventures.. if that works..
January 17th, 2010 at 4:18 pm
Dear Melisa
Yes right!!! you find out the real story of Kerala women problems.
shinod ap
January 20th, 2010 at 11:48 pm
Stumbled upon your page through Twitter.
As a Malayali, I can only apologise. But I know exactly what you feel, as my foreign wife felt similarly uncomfortable in Kerala (and lots of other parts of India) when we went a-visiting.
Re. Kerala’s sex starved society, this interview with Paul Zacharia jsut about sums it up: http://news.rediff.com/interview/2010/jan/20/there-is-a-lot-of-sex-starvation-in-kerala.htm
January 21st, 2010 at 1:00 am
Hi melissa.
I like ur blog.
January 22nd, 2010 at 2:47 pm
You see from what I’ve seen in kerala the root cause of all this; contrary to popular beliefs is not the lack of education or the value system or the conservative mentality.
The root cause is the fact that men is kerala have plenty of TIME on their hands during a ‘normal kerala day’ to indulge in all this petty nonsense. Absolute lack of ways to spend time productively is the reason for this. Thats y they spend life… a comment here, a finger there etc etc.
Theres one consolation though. Genetically we ‘mal males’ are a scared lot. Hence you’ll see 1 rape case : 999999999 cases of eve teasing, fingering in buses and theatres.
One stern look from the woman and a stern “F@** Off” loudly and you’ll see “great balls of steel” vaporizing in the quintessential malayalee MAN 😉
January 23rd, 2010 at 2:11 pm
Stumbled on this blog. You have honestly ripped off the fascade of the ’empowered women of Kerala’ and exposed the harsh realities a woman has to face in this ‘literate’ state.
As for Kerala having the highest suicide rates, one of the reasons is that all suicides are recorded in Kerala unlike other states in India where suicides are far more, where suicides are not recorded and not recognised.
January 25th, 2010 at 1:02 am
Hi Melisa, I came across your blog via your Twitter. That was a good entry. I have to agree with everything you said. I am a guy who was born and brought up in Mumbai/India and now living in US of A. As sad as this sounds, I have to say, I would never go back and live in India. Even in progressive cities like Mumbai women are mistreated, there is rampant corruption, poor infrastructure, and so on. India is a society that is living in 2 or even 3 centuries at once. I have to commend your courage and will that you are still in India after all that you have seen and experienced. Your husband is extremely lucky to have a wife like you!
March 25th, 2010 at 10:31 pm
Sadly Melissa, it’s all true. For all the talk of being a forward thinking state, we remain grossly perverted in these matters. I wish I could say things are changing for the better but not really.. Things remain the same even after 2 decades here in Kerala.. I can vouch for that fact
March 25th, 2010 at 10:43 pm
Apologies for the trouble that you have gone through. It’s a sad & bitter truth about our state and most people turn a blind eye towards it. There is no point in going to a 100 temples, churches & mosques while this kind of stuff happens in our state and we sit back and let it happen. Why only brave girls should face up to these idiotic morons? Us guys too should whack anyone who mistreats any women – Indian or foreigner!
Until things like this is sorted out, God’s own country is just words!
March 26th, 2010 at 9:22 am
True , But Most of the women are not reporting the cases. You done a Good Job, Keep Blogging.
March 26th, 2010 at 12:16 pm
I do not fully agree , its the mind set of male dominated society and the submission of the women folks.With the vast population of women working, it does’nt matter any more.In life growth all man and woman are same.Women have to be a women when she needs to be and be a man to stand up to truth.I support all woman with thier foot forward.You’re are both Shiva and Shathi.What else do you need just be what you want and move on.
Love kumaran
April 4th, 2010 at 8:05 pm
Landed up from twitter seeing your kerala male attitude topic trending on my time line. As a malayali aka keralite I completely accept what u have scribbled. Never feel that all the males in Kerala are alike. There are some 4% or 5% males who are unable to control their feelings.
“I now understand the reason for women’s lines in all public places. Really, though, the women’s lines don’t work. While the women are in the line, men are harassing them from the men’s line. This is the same reason there is a woman’s area on all buses”
Thats a fact. Kerala is the only place where we have special seats for ladies in bus and special lines for ladies which never works.
Hope u will have peaceful days ahead.. God bless U…
October 29th, 2012 at 1:48 pm
Every word is true. I’m from Kochi and I’ve experienced it all. I’m really embarassed by the condition of my state…
Anyways take care… 🙂
October 29th, 2012 at 8:39 pm
hey melissa, found your website from https://www.facebook.com/kochitips/posts/424288577624914
interesting discussion/debate going on about your post, you are missing out.
October 29th, 2012 at 9:41 pm
Thanks for letting me know. I was wondering where all the blog traffic was coming from.
October 30th, 2012 at 1:43 am
Gods own country, Devils own people !!!!
November 4th, 2012 at 8:15 am
very sad to hear this 🙁
November 4th, 2012 at 8:18 am
very sad to hear this. 🙁
June 10th, 2013 at 8:12 am
What’s up colleagues, how is all, and what you wish for to say on the topic of this post, in my view its actually amazing in favor of me.
July 28th, 2013 at 1:47 pm
Having read this I thought it was rather informative.
I appreciate you finding the time and energy to put this content together.
I once again find myself personally spending way too much time both reading and commenting.
But so what, it was still worth it!